The number is evidence about the government, not the pirate
The bounty is the best gift any franchise has handed this site, and the worst
trap. It’s canon and it’s a number. A body with global reach and excellent
intelligence issues it, and the characters quote it at each other. Everything
about it begs to be used as a ranking.
It isn’t one, and the manga is open about that. The World Government sets
bounties, and the World Government is a side in the conflict. It prices what a
person costs it: the damage they do to its institutions, the example they set,
the number of member states that complain. Strength is one input among several,
and not the biggest.
That has three consequences, and you can see all three in the ranking above.
Marines have no bounties. Not small ones. None. Garp fought Roger across his
whole career and beat the Rocks Pirates, and his figure is blank, because a
government doesn’t post a reward for its own officer. Rank by bounty and you
quietly delete the entire navy, which is roughly half the strongest people in
the world.
The number lags reality. It only changes when the government notices, which
is always after the fact. Every figure here is a snapshot of what someone
believed on one particular day, working from incomplete reports.
And it can be simply wrong. Buggy proves the rest. He holds the
eighth-largest bounty ever issued because two partners were mistaken for his
subordinates, and because his own crew made a Cross Guild flyer that showed him
at the front. Nobody lied to the government. It read the evidence it had and
reached a conclusion that anyone reading the same chapter can see is false.
That’s what a published ranking looks like from the outside. Keep it in mind
while you read this one.
Our ranking makes a different kind of claim from the bounty list, rather than a
better-informed version of it. It rests on what a chapter shows someone doing,
and that has its own weak spot. The story is still being serialised, and a
chapter published after this page could move anyone on it. We print the bounties
alongside because the disagreement between the two is more interesting than
either one.