What the Guild publishes, and what each number is about
Three separate systems get called a rating in this series and none of them
measures an animal.
A quest star is a property of the job. The official manual for Generations
puts it plainly — the number of stars represents the quest’s difficulty level —
and World runs one to nine, then master rank one to six. The same Kirin is the
target of quests at five, eight, nine, master five and master six. There is no
star on the monster.
A hunter rank belongs to the hunter and gates which quests appear. Two hunts
can share a star rating and require different ranks.
A threat level in the New World applies only to tempered individuals, in
three bands. It is not even stable per species: a Pink Rathian is band one in
master rank and band two in high rank, which makes it a label about the hunt
wearing the animal’s name. Rise later publishes a genuine per-species rating in
the ecology tab, and Wilds publishes something different again, attached to the
individual monster in front of you. Three games, three scales, one word.
The category at the top is a drawer
Threat level three in the New World contains six monsters, and all six are elder
dragons. That looks like a finding until you ask what the classification means,
at which point the game answers without being pushed. Seliana’s analytics
director describes the group as phenomena rather than animals — disasters and
forces of nature — and admits the label gets applied wherever ordinary sorting
fails. The chief ecologist, after the Nergigante study, is blunter still.
The clearest evidence that this is filing rather than measurement is a monster
that left. Akantor was taken to be an elder dragon and was moved out once a
possible relation to a known group turned up. Nothing about the animal changed.
Wilds then shipped an entire mainline game with no elder dragons in it at all.
Its flagship is classified a flying wyvern and its low-rank final boss is filed
as a construct. The category sat out a whole release and the series did not
notice.
Why the top bracket is at the bottom of this page
Monster Hunter stages exactly one kind of comparison: a turf war, where two large
monsters fight in front of the player and the game records an outcome. Wins,
draws and coin flips are all it reports — there are no damage figures, and any
source quoting them has invented them.
Read against that record the Guild’s top bracket does badly. Nergigante draws
with every elder dragon it meets. Teostra and Kushala Daora draw with each other
and with it. Velkhana draws eleven times and wins nothing. Kirin loses. The one
exception is Vaal Hazak, which beats Odogaron, and it is ranked in the tier above
for that reason rather than despite it.
This is a claim about what is depicted and not a prediction about a fight that
was never staged. Nergigante is described as preying on elder dragons and the
description may well be true; it is simply not the thing the games show, and this
page ranks on the second.