What each of them is ranked on
Gohan · rank 4 · The top seven
Beast — manga
The form debuts in a film, then does the thing that matters in the manga. In a spar, Gohan breaks through Goku's perfected ultra instinct with a clean hit, hard enough to knock him out of the form. Others have hit Goku in that state, and Black Frieza knocked him out of its true variant. It's one proven success against the top of the old order, with far fewer fights behind it than the men he startled.
shownDragon Ball Super (manga) · Super Hero arc
Strikes Goku while Goku is in mastered ultra instinct. — 2024
shownDragon Ball Super (manga) · ch. 103
The strike comes in a sparring match on Beerus's planet, which Goku halts so Broly can take his place. — 2024
shownDragon Ball Super: Super Hero · 2022
The Beast transformation debuts and defeats Cell Max.
Son Goku · rank 5 · The top seven
manga · anime · films
Goku has the longest record of anybody here, and he's fifth because several of the people above him have scored on him directly. Ultra instinct is the real thing. The narration describes it as moving without deciding to, and the panels back that up by having him dodge things he isn't looking at. The screen and the page agree about him more consistently than about anyone else in the franchise.
shownDragon Ball Super (manga) · Universe Survival arc
Fights Jiren in ultra instinct in the tournament's final stage. — 2018
shownDragon Ball Z · Frieza Saga
Defeats Frieza on Namek as a Super Saiyan. — 1991
What this does not settle
Who would win. No fight between them is on record, so nothing on this page is a result. The order above comes from everything each of them has been shown doing, cited in the two columns.
If the cited works ever show a decisive fight between them, that record gets its own page and replaces this one.