What each of them is ranked on
Kaido · rank 3 · The ones everyone else is compared to
Of the Beasts — present
Kaido's record is mostly a list of other people failing. He's been captured, imprisoned and put to death by people with every reason to make it stick, and none of it took. Nobody else here has that much evidence for being hard to kill. He's also the highest-ranked character here we actually see beaten, at Wano, which is why he's third and not first.
statedOne Piece · ch. 957
Bounty of ฿4,611,100,000. — 2019
shownOne Piece · Wano
Defeated and dropped into the magma beneath the country. — 2022
shownOne Piece · ch. 951–954
Fights Big Mom on Onigashima for days; they stop and announce an alliance. — 2019
Charlotte Linlin · rank 5 · The ones everyone else is compared to
Big Mom — present
Big Mom runs a country partly populated by her own children, and its economy is built on a power that takes years off people by asking for them. The kingdom isn't what places her, though. It's how she handles damage: in a single arc she's dropped, buried, electrocuted and set on fire, and she keeps getting up. Finishing her took two captains working together and a hole in the ground.
statedOne Piece · ch. 957
Bounty of ฿4,388,000,000. — 2019
shownOne Piece · Wano
Defeated by Eustass Kid and Trafalgar Law acting together. — 2022
What this does not settle
Who would win. No fight between them is on record, so nothing on this page is a result. The order above comes from everything each of them has been shown doing, cited in the two columns.
If the cited works ever show a decisive fight between them, that record gets its own page and replaces this one.