The connecting record
statedTokyo Ghoul · vol. 8, ch. 69
Kishou Arima beat Yoshimura in Tokyo Ghoul.
Told in the flashback to the Owl's attack on the 2nd ward; Arima, then a rank 2 investigator, used other investigators' quinques.
What each of them is ranked on
The winner · Kishou Arima · rank 2
The CCG's Reaper; secretly the One-Eyed King
Arima killed Hikari Kirishima at sixteen and beat Yoshimura at nineteen. In Route V14, after killing dozens of ghouls alone, he put IXA through Kaneki's stomach and eye, fired Narukami at him, and left him beaten. In Cochlea he drove Ayato, Touka and Yomo off with Narukami and IXA, cut Haise's legs off, and took Haise's arms with Owl. When Kaneki broke Owl, he conceded, cut his own throat, and told Kaneki as he died that he was a half human bred in the Sunlit Garden.
statedTokyo Ghoul · vol. 12, ch. 112
Yomo says Arima killed his sister Hikari.
shownTokyo Ghoul · vol. 14, ch. 138
IXA's attack pierces Kaneki's stomach, and Arima then impales his eye.
shownTokyo Ghoul · vol. 14, ch. 139
Fires Narukami at Kaneki and finishes him with IXA.
All 9 citations
shownTokyo Ghoul:re · vol. 7, ch. 65
Stabs Shachi's eye and drives Narukami through his throat.
shownTokyo Ghoul:re · vol. 7, ch. 69
Breaks Ayato's mask and strikes his leg until he cannot move.
shownTokyo Ghoul:re · vol. 7, ch. 73
Cuts off both of Haise's legs.
shownTokyo Ghoul:re · vol. 7, ch. 75
Impales Haise with Owl's blade from below and cuts off both his arms.
statedTokyo Ghoul:re · vol. 8, ch. 83
Tells Kaneki he is a half human bred by the Sunlit Garden, and asks him to take credit for his death.
statedTokyo Ghoul:re · vol. 8, ch. 86
He is revealed to have been the One-Eyed King.
Beaten · Yoshimura · rank 5
The Non-Killing Owl; manager of Anteiku
Ran the coffee shop Anteiku, a refuge for the ghouls of the 20th ward. Ten years before the story he attacked the CCG's 2nd ward office in his daughter's place, and Arima beat him and tore out the kakuhou that became the quinque Owl. In the Anteiku raid his kakuja overwhelmed Houji, Shinohara and Iwao Kuroiwa at once, and it took those three with Juuzou and Koori Ui to bring him down. Juuzou lost a leg taking his arm.
statedTokyo Ghoul · vol. 8, ch. 69
In the flashback, Arima beats him using the special classes' quinques.
shownTokyo Ghoul · vol. 13, ch. 129
Recovers from the joint attack of Houji, Shinohara and Kuroiwa and overwhelms them.
shownTokyo Ghoul · vol. 14, ch. 134
Juuzou cuts off his left arm and loses his own right leg doing it.
All 5 citations
shownTokyo Ghoul · vol. 14, ch. 135
Kuroiwa loses his left arm to him before Houji's Chi She subdues him.
statedTokyo Ghoul:re · vol. 7, ch. 74
Arima says Owl was made from the kakuhou of the Non-Killing Owl.
What this does not settle
One fight in one work. It is the only result the record gives between these two, and it is evidence about that meeting and nothing wider — not a general matchup, not a rematch, and not a ranking of its own.
The ranking is argued from everything either of them has been shown doing; this page is argued from one citation.
Where the two disagree, the disagreement is the point, and it stays visible rather than being resolved by whichever of them happens to be on this page.