Every recorded result
shownThe Two Towers · Book III ch. 10 “The Voice of Saruman”Ranking holds
Gandalf beat Saruman in The Two Towers.
Casts him from the order and the Council, says his staff is broken, and it splits in his hand. Saruman crawls away.
The cleanest win by one wizard over another in the books, with no duel and no blows. Gandalf says the staff is broken and it breaks. Saruman had held the Grey prisoner on top of the same tower a few months earlier. The change between those two scenes is the change between the two forms of this entry, and it is why the ranking puts them so far apart.
shownThe Two Towers (film) · Edoras, the healing of ThéodenRanking holds
Gandalf beat Saruman in The Two Towers (film).
Drives Saruman out of Théoden, who had been held from Isengard. The book has no possession. There, Théoden is lifted from Wormtongue's counsel.
A film-only result. The book's Théoden is sick from Wormtongue's talk and gets up when Gandalf shows him the sky. The film turns the same scene into a contest of staffs, with Saruman inside the king. The White wins it from a distance. The only film fight Saruman wins between the two is the Orthanc duel, against the Grey.
shownThe Fellowship of the Ring (film) · Orthanc, the duel of the wizardsUpset
Saruman beat Gandalf in The Fellowship of the Ring (film).
A film-only duel. In the book Gandalf says only "They took me" and that he was set on the pinnacle; no fight is described.
What each of them is ranked on
2 wins · Gandalf · rank 7
Mithrandir, Olórin
Held the Bridge of Khazad-dûm against the Balrog, broke its sword with Glamdring, and broke the bridge under it. The whip dragged him down, and he chased the thing through the roots of the mountain and up the Endless Stair. He threw it down from the peak, and then died. He won that fight as a wizard sent in an old man's body, under orders to stay humble, and it is what puts him above every Elf. Sent back as the White, he broke Saruman's staff with one sentence at Orthanc. In the extended film the Witch-king breaks his staff in the streets of Minas Tirith. In the book he stops the Witch-king under the arch, and Rohan's horns sound before a blow is struck.
shownThe Fellowship of the Ring · Book II ch. 5 “The Bridge of Khazad-dûm”
On the bridge, Glamdring meets the Balrog's flaming sword, and the Balrog's sword flies up in molten fragments.
shownThe Fellowship of the Ring · Book II ch. 5 “The Bridge of Khazad-dûm”
Smites the bridge with his staff, which breaks; the bridge cracks at the Balrog's feet and it falls, lashing its whip about his knees and dragging him after it.
statedThe Two Towers · Book III ch. 5 “The White Rider”
Tells how he threw down his enemy from the peak, and then darkness took him, and he was sent back naked for a brief time until his task is done.
All 8 citations
statedThe Two Towers · Book III ch. 5 “The White Rider”
Says he is very dangerous, more dangerous than anything they will ever meet unless brought alive before the seat of the Dark Lord.
statedThe Lord of the Rings, Appendix B · The Tale of Years, headnote to The Third Age
The Istari were forbidden to match Sauron's power with power, or to dominate Elves or Men by force and fear, and came in the shape of Men.
shownThe Return of the King · Book V ch. 4 “The Siege of Gondor”
Alone on Shadowfax before the broken Gate, he orders the Lord of the Nazgûl back; the Witch-king raises his sword, and the horns of Rohan sound before any blow falls.
shownThe Fellowship of the Ring (film) · The Bridge of Khazad-dûm
Breaks the bridge under the Balrog with his staff after the line “You shall not pass!” and is dragged down by its whip.
shownThe Return of the King (film) · Extended edition, the Witch-king at Minas Tirith
The Witch-king breaks Gandalf's staff, and the horns of Rohan sound before he can strike Gandalf down.
1 win · Saruman · rank 21
Curunír, Saruman the White
Held Gandalf the Grey prisoner on the top of Orthanc. The book has Gandalf taken and set there after he refuses to join Saruman. In the film the two wizards fight it out with their staffs, and Saruman throws Gandalf around the chamber before putting him on the pinnacle. He was the head of Gandalf's order and raised an army in Isengard. Yet after Isengard falls, Gandalf breaks his staff with a sentence and Saruman crawls away. He is a Maia like Gandalf, and a Maia ranked below the First Age Elves is the plainest example of the decline.
statedThe Fellowship of the Ring · Book II ch. 2 “The Council of Elrond”
Gandalf says that after he refused Saruman, they took him and set him alone on the pinnacle of Orthanc.
statedThe Fellowship of the Ring · Book II ch. 2 “The Council of Elrond”
Gandalf reports that Saruman was mustering a great force of wolves and Orcs in Isengard, in rivalry of Sauron.
shownThe Two Towers · Book III ch. 10 “The Voice of Saruman”
His staff splits asunder in his hand when Gandalf says it is broken, and he falls back and crawls away.
All 4 citations
shownThe Fellowship of the Ring (film) · Orthanc, the duel of the wizards
Hurls Gandalf about the chamber with his staff, takes Gandalf's staff from him, and imprisons him on the top of Orthanc.
What this does not settle
3 results, each cited, and the tally counts every one of them the same. That is its rough edge: a win at one side's lowest weighs as much as a win at its peak, which is why a level score goes to the latest result rather than to a judgement about which fight mattered. It is a record of meetings, not a ranking of its own.
The ranking is argued from everything either of them has been shown doing; this page is argued from these 3 citations.
Where the two disagree, the disagreement is the point, and it stays visible rather than being resolved by whichever of them happens to be on this page.